Skip to main content

Art as Representation

The concept of "art as representation" has been a cornerstone of aesthetic/art theory since antiquity, evolving significantly from its initial formulation as mere imitation to a more nuanced understanding of "aboutness." The historical development of this theory, primarily drawing upon the insights of Plato and Aristotle, and extend to the contemporary "neo-representational" theory, which seeks to encompass a broader spectrum of artistic expression.

Study the PDF below (for academic use only)

The earliest and arguably most enduring theory of art in Western philosophy is the Mimetic Theory of Art, championed by Plato and his student Aristotle. Derived from the Greek word mimesis, meaning "imitation" or "mimicry," this theory posits that art is fundamentally a reflection of nature. For Plato and Aristotle, an artwork must necessarily be an imitation of something—be it a person, place, object, action, or event. The quality of "verisimilitude," or truth-likeness, was highly valued, as exemplified by the ancient Greek stories of the painter Zeuxis, whose painted grapes were so realistic that birds attempted to eat them.

However, Plato's view of art was largely critical. He considered art to be:

Useless: In his metaphysics, art was an "imitation of an imitation," thus far removed from true reality (the Forms). It offered no new knowledge and served no practical purpose, likening it to merely holding up a mirror to the world. This aligns with his "Allegory of the Cave," where prisoners mistake shadows for reality, much like art presents a mere shadow of truth.

Deceptive: Plato argued that artists were unconcerned with facts or truth. The success of their works did not depend on the veracity of their depictions, potentially leading people away from genuine knowledge.

Dangerous: He believed art appealed primarily to the senses and appetites, neglecting the intellect. According to Plato's tripartite theory of the human person (appetitive, rational, spirited), art could disrupt the ideal balance where reason governs, thereby being psychologically destabilising and politically destructive.

Aristotle, while agreeing that art was essentially mimesis, offered a more favourable and nuanced defence. He rejected Plato's notion that mimesis was mere mirroring. For Aristotle, art was not simply a passive copy but the outcome of a complex mental process involving rendering (perception), construing, drawing/illustrating, idealising, and finally, representing. These intellectual acts meant that good art could put forth "ideal truths"—what something ought to be—rather than just what it is.

Furthermore, Aristotle challenged Plato's bias against sensual pleasures. He argued that humans are not just "embodied intellects" but possess other faculties, including emotions. Therefore, art, by engaging the senses, could be a way to acquire knowledge and broaden one's worldview. Crucially, Aristotle introduced the "Doctrine of Catharsis," suggesting that while art might stir up emotions, it also purges them in a harmless and healthy manner. Thus, for Aristotle, art was a natural and beneficial, even therapeutic, part of human life.

Aristotle's reinterpretation transformed the "imitation theory" into a "representation theory." Representation, in this broader sense, means something intended to stand for something else, recognized as such by an audience. It encompasses not just looking like or resembling, but also standing for something or someone, and "re-presenting" it. This expanded view provided greater generality, allowing for art that might not be a direct imitation but still conveyed meaning.

However, even this reconstructed representational theory faced limitations, particularly with the advent of art forms that do not overtly represent or imitate nature. Architecture, for instance, often serves functional and aesthetic purposes without being representational. More significantly, the rise of Abstract Art in the 20th century posed a direct challenge, as many acclaimed abstract works do not depict recognisable objects or scenes.

This challenge led to the development of the "neo-representational theory of art." This advanced theory proposes that to qualify as a work of art, a piece must possess "aboutness." That is, it must have semantic (meaning) content and a subject about which it expresses something. This theory allows for the inclusion of works like Marcel Duchamp's readymades, such as "Fountain" or "In Advance of the Broken Arm." While an ordinary urinal or snow shovel is not "about" anything and is "mute," Duchamp's readymades, by virtue of being chosen and presented by an artist, demand interpretation and possess "aboutness." They shift the viewer's engagement from the purely "retinal" to the "intellectual," prompting questions about their meaning and context.

The theory of art as representation has undergone a significant evolution. From Plato's initial, critical view of art as a deceptive imitation, through Aristotle's more benevolent reinterpretation emphasising art's intellectual and therapeutic benefits, to the contemporary neo-representational theory focusing on "aboutness" and semantic content, the understanding of how art represents has broadened considerably. This progression reflects a continuous effort to define the necessary and sufficient conditions for an item to be considered an artwork, acknowledging the diverse forms and functions of art across history and cultures.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Visual Analysis: SEMIOTICS

 Visual analysis is a systematic and scientific approach to examining visual materials that goes far beyond casual observation.  In our visually saturated world, images have become a inescapable universal language that shapes our perceptions, attitudes, and experiences. From the artworks adorning gallery walls to the advertisements lining city streets, visuals communicate narratives, evoke emotions, and reflect sociocultural ideologies. However, the process of seeing and interpreting visuals is not as spontaneous or natural as we often assume. As John Berger notably stated, "seeing is an active decision," suggesting that the process of interpreting visuals is neither spontaneous nor natural, but rather requires conscious effort and critical thinking. The way we perceive and interpret visual content is heavily influenced by habits, conventions, and our individual perspectives.  Serious visual analyses requires conscious effort and critical analysis to unravel the laye...

The Brown Sisters: A Four-Decade Portrait of Time and Sisterhood

 Nicholas Nixon's "The Brown Sisters" stands as one of photography's most compelling longitudinal portrait studies, documenting four decades of sisterhood through annual black-and-white photographs taken from 1975 to 2014. Using an 8×10 inch view camera, Nixon captured his wife Bebe and her three sisters—Heather, Mimi, and Laurie Brown—in the same order each year, creating a remarkable visual meditation on time, aging, and familial bonds. For the full set of images see the PDF below (for academic use only) Forty Portraits in Forty Years PDF What began as a spontaneous family photograph in 1975 evolved into a profound artistic documentation of human transformation. The project's strength lies in its methodological consistency: the sisters maintain their positions, with the sequence remaining unchanged throughout the series. This rigid framework paradoxically highlights the subtle changes that occur year by year, creating a powerful commentary on the passage of time...

Mass Media: Platforms and Content

 Mass Media today is interplay between technological infrastructure and creative expressions. Mass media, defined as channels of communication designed to reach large audiences, has undergone profound transformation in recent decades. What began as predominantly print-based communication has expanded into a multifaceted ecosystem encompassing visual, audio, and interactive modes of engagement. This essay explores the dialectical relationship between media platforms and content, arguing that the two elements exist in dynamic tension—with platforms shaping content possibilities while content innovations drive platform evolution. As Marshall McLuhan famously observed, "the medium is the message," suggesting that the vehicle of communication fundamentally alters how we perceive and process information. This principle remains relevant as we navigate an increasingly fragmented media landscape characterised by both institutional and user-generated content. The Architecture of Mass M...

Visual Culture

 Visual culture is a multifaceted field that examines the pervasive role of visuals in shaping human understanding, beliefs, and behaviours. It posits that visuals are not merely reflections of reality but rather "constructed realities" that actively influence our perception of the world. At its heart, visual culture positions visuals as the reference and data for knowledge, beliefs, thinking, creations, behaviour, etc.; which in turn further shapes current beliefs, thinking, creations, behaviour, etc. Visuals are images/collection of images that are made to be seen. Framed (made) and put out. This highlights that visuals are not spontaneous occurrences but deliberate constructions, detached from the place and time in which it first made its appearance, says, John Berger. Examples like the contrasting Newsweek and TIME magazine covers of O.J. Simpson illustrate how different framings of the same event can convey distinct messages and narratives, underscoring the idea that w...

A Critical Visual Analysis of Jan Banning's ‘Bureaucratics’

 Jan Banning's photographic series Bureaucratics offers a remarkable anthropological study of civil servants across eight countries, revealing how power, hierarchy, and cultural identity manifest in governmental spaces. Through meticulously composed photographs taken from a citizen's perspective, Banning unveils the theatre of bureaucracy the most immediate visual impact comes from Banning's consistent methodology: each photograph is taken from the same height and distance, positioning the viewer in the role of a citizen approaching the bureaucrat's desk. The bureaucrats are photographed in their natural habitat – their offices – which become stages where power dynamics and cultural values are performed daily. Make visual analysis of  Bureaucratics  by Jan Banning given below. Bureaucratics by Jan Banning PDF  (for academic use only) In examining the spatial arrangements, a clear pattern emerges: the desk serves as both barrier and symbol of authority. In many image...

'The Problem We All Live With'—A Little Girl's Giant Steps

 Sometimes the most powerful revolutions begin with the smallest steps. In 1960, a six-year-old girl named Ruby Bridges took such steps—walking through a screaming mob to attend her first day of school. Her courage was so profound that it moved a nation and inspired one of America's greatest artists to capture her story in a painting that would hang in the White House decades later. Ruby Bridges was born on September 8, 1954—the same year the Supreme Court declared school segregation unconstitutional. Yet six years later, when a federal judge ordered New Orleans schools to integrate, Ruby found herself walking alone into history. She was one of only six Black children who passed the tests to attend the previously all-white William Frantz Elementary School. While other families chose different paths, Ruby's mother made a decision that would echo through generations: "This is important—not just for Ruby, but for all the children who will come after her." On November 14,...

Visual Analysis: INTRODUCTION

 Visual analysis is a systematic and scientific examination of visual materials that explores their communicative meaning, aesthetic qualities, and functional impact. As Susan Sontag noted, humans tend to linger in "mere images of the truth," making it crucial to develop a deeper understanding of visual interpretation. Study the PDF below (for academic use only) Introduction to Visual Analysis PDF The Nature of Seeing: The process of seeing is not as spontaneous or natural as commonly believed. According to John Berger, our way of seeing art has historically been influenced by privileged minorities to maintain social and economic dominance. Visual perception requires conscious effort and is heavily influenced by habits and conventions. The visual faculty consumes approximately two-third of a person’s used energy, highlighting its significance in human experience. The Framework of Visual Analysis: Visual analysis could be traced back to communication models, for example, Har...